Hidden Triple Sudoku Technique

Updated

A hidden triple is three digits that between them can only go in the same three cells of a unit, which reserves those cells for the triple and removes every other candidate from them.

When a hidden triple applies

The rule is about coverage, not about individual cells. Pick three digits a unit still needs and collect every cell where any of them can go. If that collection has exactly three cells, the three digits must occupy them, one each, and no fourth digit can squeeze in.

Unlike a hidden pair, the three digits do not all need the same list of homes. One digit might be limited to two of the cells and another to all three. What matters is that the union of their homes is three cells wide.

Hidden triples are worth hunting on hard puzzles because the cells involved are often very wide. Stripping a five-candidate cell down to three in a single move is the sort of progress that restarts a stalled grid.

Worked example

The bottom-right box confines 3, 4 and 8 to r5c9, r6c8 and r6c9. Those three cells are cleaned out, which the solver reports as five eliminations.
c1c2c3c4c5c6c7c8c9
r169237131784545
r245769698312
r3183245697
r484569567912569312792559
r5315957892594727964589
r67256956891569141934534589
r7571486292339
r8934172586
r926835359471
Pattern cells
r5c9, r6c8, r6c9
Eliminations
5 from r5c9, 9 from r5c9, 5 from r6c8, 5 from r6c9, 9 from r6c9

The bottom-right box has eight empty cells, so nothing about it looks tidy. Trace the three digits anyway. 3 fits only in r6c8 and r6c9. 4 fits only in r5c9, r6c8 and r6c9. 8 fits only in r5c9 and r6c9. Together those digits reach exactly three cells.

Those cells must therefore hold 3, 4 and 8 in some order. r5c9 was carrying 4, 5, 8 and 9 and gives up the 5 and the 9. r6c8 was carrying 3, 4 and 5 and gives up the 5. r6c9 was carrying 3, 4, 5, 8 and 9 and gives up the 5 and the 9. The box has lost its only homes for 5 outside the triple, which sets up the next deduction.

How to spot a hidden triple

  1. Choose a unit and list its missing digitsBoxes with many blanks are the best hunting ground, because intersections have usually already thinned their candidates.
  2. Note the homes of every missing digitWrite down, for each digit, the cells in the unit where it can still go. Digits with two or three homes are the interesting ones.
  3. Look for three digits covering three cellsCombine three of those home lists. If the union is exactly three cells, the triple is confirmed.
  4. Clean the three cellsRemove every candidate other than the three digits from all three cells, then look for the naked subset or single that appears next.

Common mistakes

Hidden triple FAQ

Do the three digits have to appear in all three cells?

No. Each digit needs at least two homes among the three cells, and the union of all three home lists must be exactly those three cells. Any distribution satisfying that is a valid hidden triple.

Where do hidden triples show up most?

In units with seven or more empty cells, most often boxes. In tighter units the equivalent naked subset is smaller and a solver will find that first.

Is a hidden triple related to a naked subset?

Yes. In a unit with n empty cells, a hidden triple on three of them is the complement of a naked subset on the other n − 3 cells. When that complement is small, the naked version is the easier way in.

Does it ever place a digit directly?

Not on its own. It only removes candidates, but the removals routinely expose a hidden single for a digit that was previously spread across the unit.